Tolerancing:
For a typical compression spring or extension spring design, the designer should specify a load or a load and a rate, but avoid tolerancing the free length.
For most applications it is the load and or rate that is important, not the free length. Leaving the free length and number of coils reference allows the spring manufacturer something to adjust in order to hold the loads.
For the same reasons, the designer should avoid specifying a tolerance on a torsion spring free position. Avoid specifying a solid height unless it is specifically needed in the spring's application.
Designing a spring with the Max solid right at the calculated solid (or worse, below) can increase manufacturing cost. The designer should, when ever possible, allow a half of a wire diameter for max solid above calculated solid to allow for variation in the amount of grind and the amount of coils. See the SMI "Spring Design Handbook" for commercial spring tolerances. |